Romantic First Dance Songs That Aren’t Overdone

After DJing over 500 weddings in Missouri, we can confirm: couples want first dance songs that feel meaningful without being the same ones everyone else uses.

Here are our favorite underrated romantic tracks you can use for your 2026 wedding.

Soft & Emotional Indie Picks

• “Bloom” – The Paper Kites

• “I Get to Love You” – Ruelle

• “You’re My Best Friend” – The Once (acoustic cover)

• “Forever” – Ben Harper

Soulful and Smooth

• “Beyond” – Leon Bridges

• “Best Part” – Daniel Caesar ft. H.E.R.

• “Conversations in the Dark” – John Legend

Modern Pop Without the Overplayed Feel

• “Lover (First Dance Remix)” – Taylor Swift (yes, but still unique)

• “Can’t Help Falling in Love” – Haley Reinhart

• “Why I Love You” – MAJOR.

Country & Folk Favorites

Huge in Missouri:

• “Then” – Brad Paisley

• “From the Ground Up” – Dan + Shay

• “Heaven” – Jason Aldean (acoustic version)

• “Made for You” – Jake Owen

For a Slightly Upbeat First Dance

• “Adore You” – Harry Styles

• “Love Someone” – Lukas Graham

• “Ho Hey” – The Lumineers (sweet & simple)